India Matters

Barack Obama argues India is “indispensable”.

Reaffirming American relations with India was one of the few foreign-policy successes of the Bush Administration. A nuclear power with impressive economic growth, India is already the South Asian superpower and likely to become more than that. It works with Brazil and Russia and even with China (the so-called “BRIC”) to strengthen its international position, and it plays a pivotal, albeit an oftentimes overlooked, role in the Middle East.

Barack Obama was wise to invite his Indian counterpart, Manmohan Singh, to the White House’s first state dinner in November; a clear sign that the administration intends for India to be part of its “multilateral” strategy.

According to the American president, India is “indispensable” in building “a future of security and prosperity for all nations.”


Singh, as finance minister during the first half of the 1990s, broke with India’s past of moderate socialism and instituted a series of reforms that carried the country out of its malaise.

As prime minister, he has continued to promote privatization and free trade while investing in a massive campaign against poverty.

Obama recognized these achievements when he declared,

As leading economies, the United States and India can strengthen the global economic recovery, promote trade that creates jobs for both our people, and pursue growth that is balanced and sustained.

Nuclear weapons

The president also recognized India’s importance to another one of his goals: bringing nuclear proliferation to a halt:

As nuclear powers, we can be full partners in preventing the spread of the world’s most deadly weapons, securing loose nuclear materials from terrorists, and pursuing our shared vision of a world without nuclear weapons.

Both countries know the “pain and anguish of terrorism,” Obama said, so they must stand together to “promote the development and prosperity that undermines violent extremism.”

Elephant in the room

Prime Minister Singh responded in kind when he argued India and the United States are “bound together” by common values and a shared dedication “to meet [the] challenges of a fast-changing world in this twenty-first century.”

There is an elephant in the room that neither leader spoke of. America is investing in Pakistan to support its war on terror at a time when India and Pakistan are accusing one another of involvements in terrorist attacks in their countries.

After fighting three wars, the two are still engaged in something of a nuclear cold war. Pervez Hoodbhoy writes for the New Atlanticist that most of India “would like to forget that Pakistan exists.” Fast on its way to becoming a superpower, India “has no need to engage a struggling Pakistan with its endless litany of problems,” according to Hoodbhoy.

That’s not how Pakistan sees it. Islamabad is by no means comfortable with India’s newfound American support. The Obama Administration will have to carefully balance its commitment to Pakistan against its relationship with India. It needs the first to bring the war in Afghanistan to a successful end, but once that’s done India is really the only country in South Asia that matters.