Programs of the French Presidential Candidates, Compared

Marine Le Pen
French party leader Marine Le Pen makes her way to a news conference in Strasbourg, May 11, 2016 (European Parliament/Fred Marvaux)

Twelve candidates have qualified to compete in the French presidential election. Only six are polling at more than few percentage points. I will summarize their policies here, plus those of Anne Hidalgo. The mayor of Paris has just 2 percent support in recent surveys, but her Socialist Party could still be a force in the legislative elections in June.

The comparison reveals strange bedfellows. The centrist Emmanuel Macron and center-right Valérie Pécresse see eye to eye on asylum and pension reform. Macron’s climate policies are closer to the Green party’s candidate, Yannick Jadot. Jadot and the far-right Marine Le Pen emphasize animal welfare. Le Pen and the far-left Jean-Luc Mélenchon agree on renationalizing motorways. Mélenchon and the far-right Éric Zemmour believe NATO is obsolete.

Emmanuel Macron

The incumbent has 26 to 28 percent support in surveys for the first voting round on April 10.

  • €50 billion to build fifty offshore wind farms and six nuclear power reactors, double onshore wind power and increase solar energy output tenfold by 2050.
  • €15 billion in tax cuts financed by administrative spending cuts.
  • Achieve 100-percent French supply chains in electric cars, solar panels and wind turbines.
  • Create 200 new gendarmerie brigades. (There are about 3,600.)
  • Cut inheritance tax.
  • Give all French a one-time, tax-free cheque of up to €6,000 to cope with inflation.
  • Hire 8,500 magistrates and judicial staff.
  • Integrate European armed forces.
  • Raise subsidies for single parents.
  • Raise teachers’ pay and give schools more autonomy.
  • Raise the retirement age from 62 to 65. Raise the minimum pension to €1,100 per month. Merge France’s 42 public pension schemes into a single, points-based system.
  • Simplify asylum procedures.

Marine Le Pen

The leader of the far-right National Rally has 17 to 21 percent support.

  • Abolish inheritance tax for low and middle incomes.
  • Ban the slaughter of conscious animals.
  • Centralize French language and history in high-school curricula.
  • Double subsidies for single parents.
  • End family reunification as criterion for residence.
  • Exempt workers under the age of 30 from income tax.
  • Give native French priority in employment and social housing.
  • Privatize public broadcasting and abolish the license fee.
  • Process asylum applications abroad, not in France.
  • Renationalize motorways to reduce tolls by 15 percent.
  • Restore mandatory minimum prison sentences and abolish early release.

Jean-Luc Mélenchon

The leader of the far-left France Unbowed is consolidating left-wing support. He polled at 9 to 11 percent earlier this year, but is now at 14-15 percent.

  • €200 billion in ecological and social investments.
  • 100-percent tax on inheritances over €12 million.
  • Ban factory farming.
  • Ensure a minimum monthly after-tax income of €1,400.
  • Guarantee jobs for all.
  • Leave NATO.
  • Legalize cannabis under a state monopoly.
  • Liberalize immigration laws.
  • Lower the pension age from 62 to 60.
  • Phase out nuclear power.
  • Raise tax on incomes over €4,000 per month.
  • Reduce the working week to 32 hours in some jobs.
  • Reinstate the wealth tax (abolished by Macron).
  • Renationalize motorways, rail and utilities.

Valérie Pécresse

The leader of the center-right Republicans has 9 to 11 percent support.

  • Condition residency on learning French.
  • Cut 200,000 administrative jobs.
  • Cut social aid for illegal immigrants.
  • Hire 25,000 caregivers and cut red tape in hospitals.
  • Introduce immigration quotas for countries and professions.
  • Raise the retirement age from 62 to 65.
  • Simplify asylum procedures.

Éric Zemmour

The leader of the new far-right party Reconquest has 9 to 11 percent support.

  • Ban non-French baby names.
  • Build 10,000 more prison cells.
  • Close the approximately 540 mosques operated by Islamists.
  • Cut €30 billion in business taxes.
  • Deport recidivists with dual nationality.
  • End family reunification as criterion for residence.
  • Leave NATO.
  • Process asylum applications abroad, not in France.
  • Restore mandatory minimum sentences.
  • Shift French foreign policy away from America and toward Russia.
  • Stipulate French preference in public procurement.
  • Stop most immigration.

Yannick Jadot

The Green party candidate has 4 to 6 percent support.

  • Ban Russian energy imports.
  • Ban short flights where trains are available.
  • Ban single-use plastics by 2030.
  • Build 3,000 onshore wind turbines and 40 km² of solar panels by 2027.
  • Cut use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides in half by 2027. (EU goal is 2030.)
  • End cage farming and reduce the amount of fish caught.
  • Equal pay for men and women.
  • Legalize cannabis.
  • Phase out nuclear power.
  • Provide legal status to migrants who have a job, family or children in school.
  • Raise tax on assets over €2 million.
  • Require medicine graduates to practice in an underserved community for three years.

Anne Hidalgo

The Socialist Party candidate has 2 percent support in most recent surveys.

  • Build 150,000 social housing units per year.
  • Cut industry greenhouse gas emissions in half by 2035.
  • Equal pay for men and women.
  • Hire more police.
  • Keep the retirement age at 62.
  • Relax debt and deficit rules in the EU.
  • Raise teachers’ pay.
  • Raise the minimum wage from €1,230 to €1,430 per month.
  • Train 15,000 new doctors per year.