Clear-Eyed Danes Have Lessons on Immigration

The Danes channel anti-immigrant sentiment through the political process and are honest about the challenges.

Women in Superkilen, a public park in Copenhagen, Denmark, March 13, 2015
Women in Superkilen, a public park in Copenhagen, Denmark, March 13, 2015 (Jan Jespersen)

As European countries struggle to cope with a record-high influx of asylum seekers this year, there is a thing or two they could learn from Denmark, writes James Kirchick in Foreign Policy magazine.

The country was the first in Western Europe to curtail immigrant marriages and last year cut social benefits for refugees nearly in half.

Such policies may be ungenerous; they have helped reduce the flow of people coming in and raise native acceptance of those immigrants who are admitted.

Channeling anti-immigrant sentiment

Whereas mainstream politicians in Germany and Sweden still largely refuses to recognize there is anything of merit in anti-immigrant sentiment and thus give worried voters little choice but to turn to the far right, pragmatic leaders in Denmark recognized decades ago that there is room for a sensible nationalism in their political discourse.

The Danish People’s Party is often lumped together with right-wing populists elsewhere, but it isn’t nearly as extreme as most and has moderated its positions in recent years.

The party usually polls around 13 percent support, going up to 21 percent in the 2015 election.

A year earlier, after the European Parliament elections, the nationalists spurned cooperation with the Dutch Freedom Party and the French Front national in favor of an alliance with Britain’s Conservatives — hardly paragons of the far right.

“Anti-migration sentiments are thus channeled in a healthy way,” argues Kirchick; through the parliamentary process, “not onto the streets.”

German and Swedish parties should take note. Demonizing the Alternative für Deutschland and Sweden Democrats, respectively, only keeps them and their voters on the outside. Better to engage and work with them in parliament to bring them into the political process.


This also means recognizing that there are real problems. You can reject the rhetoric or the solutions of the far right without dismissing their grievances as racist or imagined.

In this sense, too, the Danes have done better. By drawing the People’s Party into informal governing arrangements, the mainstream center-right parties implicitly acknowledged it had a point about the failings of multiculturalism.

Unemployment rates are higher among Denmark’s predominantly Muslim immigrant community, as is dependence on welfare. Even the children of immigrants are sometimes slow to learn Danish and end up on the margins of society — where they can be susceptible to radicalization.

Denmark has seen what that can do. Its Jyllands-Posten newspaper caused a stir around the world when it printed cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad in 2005. One of the artists still receives death threats up to this day.

Last year, a Dane who attended a meeting in Copenhagen with Swedish cartoonist Lars Vilks, also known for drawing an unflattering portrait of the prophet, was killed by a Muslim fanatic. Three police officers were injured before the perpetrator was shot.

In light of that, it’s little wonder the Danes have abandoned cultural relativism in favor of restrictive immigration as well as uncompromising integration policies.

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.